One brief · three ways to guide a revision

What actually changed the Runbook dashboard?

These are paired browser captures of two models improving their own existing React pages. Compare A and B before opening each reveal. Decide which is easier to use and which you would keep.

Four bounded revisions, same synthetic content and shared checks. Pairs 01–03 share one model and baseline. This is a design review, not a model ranking. The interactive builds use only local static files.

01

Runbook · paired review

Less framing

Before opening the reveal: which version makes the runs easier to scan, and which would you keep? Click a capture to inspect it full size.

AVersion A
Pair 01, version A, desktop dashboard Pair 01, version A, full mobile dashboard
BVersion B
Pair 01, version B, desktop dashboard Pair 01, version B, full mobile dashboard
Reveal the route and sources

Route: Impeccable shape + critique. Version A is luna-impeccable; version B is luna-baseline.

The revision removes some card framing and increases type and row sizing, while keeping the same list/detail order. It passes all five shared checks.

Try ATry BA stylesB styles

02

Runbook · paired review

List and selected result

Before opening the reveal: which version makes the runs easier to scan, and which would you keep? Click a capture to inspect it full size.

AVersion A
Pair 02, version A, desktop dashboard Pair 02, version A, full mobile dashboard
BVersion B
Pair 02, version B, desktop dashboard Pair 02, version B, full mobile dashboard
Reveal the route and sources

Route: Drawn reference + token sheet. Version A is luna-baseline; version B is luna-reference.

The revision changes hierarchy most: a side-by-side desktop list/detail, warmer palette, and more legible headings. On mobile, several metadata labels remain tiny.

Try ATry BA stylesB styles

03

Runbook · paired review

Reading the runs

Before opening the reveal: which version makes the runs easier to scan, and which would you keep? Click a capture to inspect it full size.

AVersion A
Pair 03, version A, desktop dashboard Pair 03, version A, full mobile dashboard
BVersion B
Pair 03, version B, desktop dashboard Pair 03, version B, full mobile dashboard
Reveal the route and sources

Route: Baseline screenshot + one critique/revision. Version A is luna-screenshot; version B is luna-baseline.

The revision modestly enlarges run names, row spacing and details. It keeps the overall structure; the effect is hard to distinguish at a glance.

Try ATry BA stylesB styles

04

Runbook · paired review

Attention and hierarchy

Before opening the reveal: which version makes the runs easier to scan, and which would you keep? Click a capture to inspect it full size.

AVersion A
Pair 04, version A, desktop dashboard Pair 04, version A, full mobile dashboard
BVersion B
Pair 04, version B, desktop dashboard Pair 04, version B, full mobile dashboard
Reveal the route and sources

Route: Impeccable shape + critique on MiMo. Version A is mimo-baseline; version B is mimo-impeccable.

The revision promotes a failed run into an attention strip. It adds a second button for the same run, fails two shared assertions, and pushes the selected result farther down on mobile.

Try ATry BA sourceB source